One Month Without A Car (31. July 2007, 14:40 by Erik) ~ Could you do it?

Last week we tried to measure walkability in Tacoma’s neighborhoods which got a lot of people looking at their own neighborhood in a new way.

Then yesterday we hear about the poor guy who flipped his car into the Marcato.

Put these two posts together and we’re left with an interesting question.

Let’s say that yesterday you crashed your car into the Marcato and found out that for the next 30 days you will be without a car (for at least one person this isn’t a hypothetical question, but for everyone else, feel free to play along).

What would you do without a car for a month? Would you pull out an old bike? Is there a bus route close to your place? If so, have you ever ridden the bus? How close is a grocery store?

Imagine what your next month would be like. Assume for the sake of argument that you’re not just going to borrow a friend’s car and that you don’t have a spare car sitting in your garage. What would be more difficult running errands or getting to work?

Could you do it?

Commenting Is Closed
Comments are allowed for two weeks from the posted date. If you want to make a comment or reopen this discussion, please contact us with your request. Thank you for visiting.

#

I have a friend, in Tacoma, who just finished taking a year off of having a car. It didn’t seem like it was incredibly difficult for her. She rode her bike a lot. That’s all it took.

1 | Posted by Kachoo | Jul 31, 03:10 PM

Been car-free for years ;-)

2 | Posted by Tacoma (A)roma | Jul 31, 03:15 PM

Could do it – two bus routes equidistant from our house, both of us live and work in Tacoma… BUT we need a car available to go to client meetings.

So a yes to most of it except the practical work thing.

Aside from that, we have nearly half our 15 employees here partaking in an alt commute of some kind (e.g. bike, bus, carpooling).

3 | Posted by KevinFreitas | Jul 31, 03:23 PM

I know an underground political cartoonist who has been operating without a car since May 1.

GO ROUTE 57!

4 | Posted by RR Anderson | Jul 31, 03:30 PM

Moderators have to play along, too. :-)

5 | Posted by Broadway resident | Jul 31, 03:33 PM

Absolutely, and if you live and work in the same area, and have other services like restaurants and grocery stores close by, I urge those folks to try it! Tacoma is a small-sized city. It’s more manageable here than people like to think, we just simply have less alt-commuters.

6 | Posted by Corey | Jul 31, 03:44 PM

Would have to purchase a bike or (other means of transportation allowed by the rules) and appropriate safety gear, etc. I assume I can’t car-pool with anyone. But a bike would get me by, and with planning, the bus would get me around town, and groceries are a short walk away. My job does require occasional meetings in far-flung places around the Sound, so it would make parts of my job very difficult. In an emergency I could do a small portion of the work from home if I bought a bigger computer. I’d probably use it as an excuse to take some vacation time, too. In summary, errands fine; getting to work a slight pain (but I’d be used to it when the month was over; work itself would have impossible days.

7 | Posted by Broadway resident | Jul 31, 03:47 PM

Hmmm…can’t remember the last time I drove to work (though I have accepted the occasional ride to/from). In fact, our “second car” typically sees well under 1000 miles/year.

However, we regularly drive to the grocery store, the gym (I know, ironic), and other errands that would be otherwise possible via bus or biking. And getting our farm share without a car might be challenging. So we’re not exactly car-free poster children…

And unfortunately, as much as I like the Tomboy, there isn’t a full service grocery store within walking distance of the Sixth Ave district. Big ding on neighborhood walkability there…

8 | Posted by jamie from thriceallamerican | Jul 31, 03:57 PM

I would just like to add that as I came down the hill to 11th and Pacific today on my bike ride to work, I saw, simultaneously, 3 other bicyclists passing through the intersection in various directions. This made me happy.

9 | Posted by jamie from thriceallamerican | Jul 31, 04:00 PM

Well, I walk, light-rail, Sounder, bus then walk again to Work, and Walk, Sounder, Walk home in the evening… So Work wouldn’t change.

Errands… Well, I’d have to change where I shop but it could be done.

10 | Posted by Joel Larson | Jul 31, 04:01 PM

I agree w/Broadway resident — WWDD? (What Would Derek Do?)

11 | Posted by KevinFreitas | Jul 31, 04:01 PM

I’m assuming that I can’t resort my motorcycle?

Flexcar would be a good option if they’d ever get their act together and place some vehicles in Tacoma. My Seattlite friends really like it.

For me, I’m thinking that the car-pool to work and shopping at lunch would cover it. For supper out on the town, I’d live it up and get a Towncar.

12 | Posted by Dave St. | Jul 31, 04:22 PM

Hmmm…this would be an interesting challenge and I imagine that anyone accepting it would learn quite a bit about him/herself and also about the her/his neighborhood.

When I lived on North G Street it would have been pretty easy to get by. Wright Park, Stadium Thriftway, the Parkway, and Stadium Video would cover the basics. Add in the odd bus trip for clothes shopping or whatnot and the only real problem would be missing all those concerts in Seattle. Shame on Sound Transit for ending bus service so early.

13 | Posted by Erik S | Jul 31, 04:42 PM

Me? No problem.

I’m a twenty minute walk from the front door to nearly anything on the north side of downtown. Link can get me to the rest of downtown. I already use my bicycle on a regular basis to get to Proctor and downtown. There’s a bus stop right around the corner.

I am a big fan of the express bus to Seattle for those occasional big city trips.

I think the most difficult thing may be picking up the farmshare in the middle of the week out on River Road. Jamie, can you pick up the farmshare for the next… month?

14 | Posted by Derek | Jul 31, 05:00 PM

It’s amazing the things a bike/bus combo can do. My commute is biking from the north end to downtown, hopping on the bus to Seattle, and riding a few miles on that end. All things considered, especially taking out parking time, biking is a quick way to get around. You just have to be ready to ride up the hill from downtown. But a little more exercise never hurt anyone.

15 | Posted by Elliot | Jul 31, 05:04 PM

“I think the most difficult thing may be picking up the farmshare in the middle of the week out on River Road. Jamie, can you pick up the farmshare for the next… month?”

Wait, is this whole question based on reality? Is that why I’m picking up the farm share this week? I thought you guys had an extra car laying around…not to mention the one in California. :-)

16 | Posted by jamie from thriceallamerican | Jul 31, 05:11 PM

What is this farmshare you all keep referencing?

17 | Posted by Tacoma (A)roma | Jul 31, 05:21 PM

“What is this farmshare you all keep referencing?”

Terry’s Berries CSA out on River Road sells farm shares, where you get an allotment of organic fruits and vegetables every week. They also sell eggs, bread from Essential Baking, and flower shares.

Anyway, because both Derek and I live in two-member households, we split a single summer share (LOTS of food). And as such, we split the duties of actually going to pick it up as well.

18 | Posted by jamie from thriceallamerican | Jul 31, 05:35 PM

I could probably take the bus to the Target and walk to work from there, though it wouldn’t be a bad bike ride. If I had a bike.

Errands are trickier. The walk to Stadium Thriftway isn’t so bad until you have orange juice and ice cream. You’d have to go two or three times a week so you weren’t carrying much each time. I’d probably also increase the number of times I take work shorts or slacks in for dry cleaning. Or maybe I’d iron more, but that seems unlikely.

I think I could probably do it pretty easily for a month. Add a flex car to the plan and I could lose the Elantra and the car insurance and save a bunch of money.

19 | Posted by Erik Hanberg | Jul 31, 05:37 PM

…not to mention the one in California.

It doesn’t count. It’s in California…

This isn’t my reality. Although I do walk and bike to ‘work’ a lot. I can pick up the farmshare next week.

20 | Posted by Derek | Jul 31, 06:28 PM

MON through FRI – walk to bus stop, ride bus, walk to work (reverse on the way home)

SAT – Take car to Federal Way. Not a lot of alternatives to FED. WAY from where I live.

SUN – Grocery Store. Could probably accomplish this by walking….

21 | Posted by snoopy | Jul 31, 06:30 PM

Oddly enough, my starter died earlier in the year and I was unable to have the time to deal with getting it fixed. I ended up walking to work for a few days, those days went to weeks, then a month, and about 6 weeks later I finally got around to getting it repaired. Net result, I use the car far less than ever before and I feel great about it!

22 | Posted by Tim Farrell | Jul 31, 08:09 PM

I live in the Stadium District and have never owned a car.

23 | Posted by kweeket | Jul 31, 08:24 PM

Ok, dose of reality time. Play the same game but do it in January when it is cold, rainy, and dark.

Would you still leave the car at home?

24 | Posted by Davest | Jul 31, 09:01 PM

I haven’t owned a car in several years and have no problems. Bus, walk, ride bikes. Though it would be nice if taxis were a bit more prevalent in this town…it seems every time I call for one they tell me it will be an hour, and it’s usually not that fast.

Enterprise in Stadium also rents compact cars for just $9 / day Friday-Monday. I could rent one every weekend and it would be cheaper than just insurance on my own car.

25 | Posted by Xerxes | Jul 31, 10:01 PM

I try to use my car only once a week. Some weeks are better then others. I ride my bicycle most days, year round to and from work. I am lucky that I only work 1 1/2 mile from my home, unless I have to go to the seattle office. Then could walk and catch the Seattle bus. Walking/bicycle/bus and carpooling makes it possible for me to use my car only once a week.

26 | Posted by Carla | Aug 1, 03:53 AM

I rarely drive. I recently received a promotion to our corporate headquarters in Kent and discovered that I could ride the train. Living in the Stadium District, I have two bus routes that can take me to the train station. When I get home at the end of the day, the thought of driving actually annoys me. As a matter of fact, my truck is currently in Federal Way at my boyfriend’s house (the last place I drove)

27 | Posted by Lisa Lawrence | Aug 1, 07:50 AM

“I would just like to add that as I came down the hill to 11th and Pacific today on my bike ride to work, I saw, simultaneously, 3 other bicyclists passing through the intersection in various directions. This made me happy.”
This makes me very happy too, I’ve noticed many more bike commuters on my route(passing me on the way back home!).I’m a fair weather rider though, it’s nice the buses run regularly for those winter months. And the Safeway is not too bad of a walk on a weekend.

28 | Posted by Kristina | Aug 1, 08:42 AM

I will have been car free for 2 years in September. Initially I lived in Lakewood, close to the Lakewood Town Center and my former employer, which made life convenient but complicated my social and cultural life. The Lakewood Town Center has, within walking distance, nearly every convenience one requires. Traveling from Lakewood to Tacoma and back in the evening by bus was not always convenient. As such I missed out on a lot of social and cultural events.

Moving to Tacoma made errands more difficult but made my social life easier. I started riding the PT Route 2 to Lakewood in the morning and riding my bicycle home. I miss my daily rides.

I now work in Seattle and live a short distance from Old Town. I use the PT Route 13 and the Sounder Train to commute. I’m spoiled now. I live with my girlfriend and she has a car. Grocery shopping and dry cleaning, two of the hardest tasks for the car-less, are now simple.

All that said I’ve lived in a few cities, in the Pacific Northwest as well as the Southeast, and Tacoma is by far the easiest to navigate without a car. Being a cyclist helps a lot!

29 | Posted by Andrew Becherer | Aug 1, 09:34 AM

I probably could do it if I were on my own. I did it for years with the help of my trusty bike. But I have four kids age thirteen and younger who go to three different schools and have outside activities. Makes it a bit too tough for me.

30 | Posted by Droid16 | Aug 1, 09:43 AM

I’d have to break out the ole Rosco Scooter.

31 | Posted by grubedoo | Aug 1, 10:06 AM

Great question!

Since moving to the Marcato (luckily it wasn’t our unit that received the drive-through), my husband takes the bus to work.
I try to have a couple of days a week that I only walk or take the bus.
If we are going out to eat in the evening we only walk.
When we have a grocery store close by, I hope to only drive twice a month to pick up my adult son from his group home in Bremerton.

Thanks for a great site!

Liz

32 | Posted by Elizabeth Burris | Aug 1, 11:00 AM

Re: “I think the most difficult thing may be picking up the farmshare in the middle of the week out on River Road. Jamie, can you pick up the farmshare for the next… month?”

Remember lovely Denise at T’s B’s? Well she has her own CSA – and guess what??? She Delivers! It’s hard to beat Terry’s but hey, no car required!

So, how many sheets of plywood do you think I could get on a city bus before I start getting the stink-eye?

33 | Posted by Mr. Madera | Aug 1, 03:09 PM

I moved from Tacoma back to Seattle, partly because it is so hard to function in Tacoma without a car. For one thing, there is no dependable cab service. There were times when I wanted to go out somewhere or even get home from work at a late hour. Since Tacoma isn’t safe due to lack of people on the street ( another difference from Seattle), it isn’t safe to take a bus at night. Due to the lack of cab service, you can also forget about grocery shopping in Tacoma without a car. I count my blessings every day that I now live in Seattle and can get a cab in 2-5 minutes from anywhere in town. The rent is higher, but you pay for what you get.

34 | Posted by maggie5 | Aug 2, 09:30 AM

I guess I’m an exception to Maggie5’s rather strident sounding rules — I live in Tacoma and often grocery shop (at Stadium Thriftway) without a car. And so far, I’ve found it just as safe as when I used to walk to grocery stores in Ballard, Fremont, or Wallingford. Shocking!

That said, I agree that density is a good thing in urban centers like Tacoma, and Tacoma would benefit in many ways from having more eyes and feet on the street.

35 | Posted by michael g. | Aug 2, 11:05 PM

No car for a month for me would mean being stuck in Gig Harbor for a month. Yuck! I can get around town just fine (I live and work in GH) by bike, but there aren’t a lot of express buses (more are in the works) and the regular bus, well it sucks.

I’ve ridden my bike to The Grand a couple of times, but that’s a 30 mile round trip.

With a few improvements to make Gig Harbor more bike friendly and more express buses you could live out here and rarely need a car.

36 | Posted by michael | Aug 2, 11:23 PM

I was talking about getting a lot of groceries and calling a cab. There was no freedom to do this in Tacoma because a lot of food would thaw out and spoil by the time the cab showed up-sometimes 2 hours later.

37 | Posted by maggie5 | Aug 3, 11:49 PM

Commenting is closed for this article.

#

  • Posted:31. July 2007, 14:40
  • Author: Erik
  • Category:
  • Comment Status:Closed

#

#